The story is narrated by 12-year-old Michael Fickett, whose minister father decides to adopt Edgar Allan, a young black orphan. At first, the family embraces Edgar and treats him as one of their own. However, they soon face racism and intolerance from their community and congregation over the interracial adoption.

Michael's 14-year-old sister Mary Nell resents Edgar's presence and gives her parents an ultimatum - either Edgar goes or she leaves. Shockingly, the parents decide to send Edgar away to avoid losing Mary Nell, despite the father's belief in equality. This decision devastates Michael, who loses respect for his father's principles.